Gelato cake costco

Gelato cake costco DEFAULT

10 fan-favorite desserts you can get from Costco

costco store
Mario Anzuoni/Reuters
  • Costco's bakery is lined with goodies that look delectable, but there are some Costo sweets that are way better than others. 
  • The warehouse retailer has several desserts that have grown their own fanbase.
  • Costco's boozy popsicles and brownie brittle are just a couple fan-favorites. 
  • Visit INSIDER's homepage for more stories.

Costco customers are constantly raving about their favorite Costco desserts. From their famous sheet cakes to their pumpkin pies, the warehouse retailer has made plenty of fans happy. And amongst these desserts, some have even become Costco cult-favorites.

To help you find those sweet hidden gems, INSIDER poked through customer reviews and Reddit threads to find out which items made the cut for the best Costco desserts.  

Sheila G’s Chocolate Chip Brownie Brittle is a longtime Costco fan-favorite.


Calling all chocoholics: you can find these thin, crispy brownie cookies in the snack section. For only $6.99, you can get a 16-oz bag of Sheila G's Brownie Brittle.

Plus, each serving is just 120 calories. 

The Universal Bakery Organic Aussie Bites may be healthy, but also a delicious dessert.


These little Aussie Bites are the perfect balance of sweetness and nutrition. They are made of dried apricots, flaxseed, sunflower seeds, honey, coconut, rolled oats, and chia seeds, and they're 100% organic. They're perfect for a snack or dessert. Costco sells32 bite-sized treats for $11.99.

The Delta cookies otherwise known as Lotus Biscoff Cookies are sold in bulk at Costco.


If you love the cookies Delta serves on its flights, then you're in for a real treat. Costco sells a 300-count pack of them for $18.99. They're individually wrapped too so you don't have to worry about them losing their freshness. They pair well with coffee, tea, and make for the perfect after-dinner treat.

Costco cheesecakes are beloved by customers.

costco pre slice cheesecake

Another dessert you can't go wrong with at Costco is their 12-inch cheesecake for $17.99, usually found by the cold section of the bakery area.Reddit fans agree that the Kirkland Signature cheesecake is one of their best desserts, and it's great for any and all occasions. You can eat it plain or add your own fruit, chocolate, or caramel topping.

Chocolate fudge cakes are great individual desserts.

1990 — Chocolate lava cake
Ekabhishek/ Wikimedia Commons

Pots & Co's chocolate lava cakes are a recent addition to the Costco dessert family. They come in four individual pots so you don't need a big crowd to bring them out. Just like the name suggests, they're chocolate cakes with a chocolatey fudge filling. Just pop them in the microwave for one minute or in the oven for 12 and they're ready to enjoy. The four-count package costs $10.99.

Costco’s cream puffs are perfect for a crowd.


For a dessert that is sure to please a crowd, bring out the Delizza Belgian Mini Cream Puffs. Reddit users saythey're very hard to stop eating. You can find the 120-count box in the frozen section for just $10.69. They serve as an excellent dessert for a large group since there are so many in one box.

Their massive carrot cake is a fan-favorite.


Costco's carrot cake was recently relaunched in stores, and customers raved on social media about their old favorite cake. Back in April, it had aresurgence in popularity. People were talking all about the 4-pound cake, perfect for Easter dessert. 

This 10-inch carrot cake is two-tiers of apricot filling, cream cheese frosting, carrot cake crumbs, and toasted walnuts all for $13.99.

Costco’s Boozy Popsicles are one of their best summer treats.

5b1953a15e48ec45008b4639 960 720
Slim Chillers/Facebook

Due to popular demand, Slim Chillers' Vodka Martini Skinny Freezers areback at Costco. They made their debut on Costco shelves last year, and customers went berserk over them.

They're back again this year, and you can find them in their four original flavors: Watermelon Lemonade, Lemon Drop, Cosmopolitan, and Appletini. Costco is selling a12-pack of these boozy popsicles for $19.99.


Who hasn’t enjoyed a slice of Costco cake? They provide delicious cakes for affordable prices, so its little surprise how popular they are!

It is true that Costco cake prices are some of the best you will likely find, and the fact they are not lacking in great choices has helped to ensure they remain a staple at many parties and special occasions.

You can get traditional round cakes in a variety of flavors, with the cheesecake, key lime cake and cinnamon butter cake to name a few. Sizes range from 44oz to 72oz, so there is also a good selection of sizes to suit your needs.

[table id=56 /]

Again, Costco cake prices are some of the cheapest around, and it is certainly the case for their round cake selections. Prices start at $6.99 reaching around $16.99 for the largest speciality round cakes, making them very affordable.

Costco’s bar and sheet cakes are equally well-priced, costing $15.99 and $18.99 respectively. These come with a number of flavours too, and they are some of the largest Costco cakes available, making them ideal for larger gatherings and celebrations.

Why Costco Cakes?

Not sure about getting a cake from Costco? There are plenty of good reasons to do so!

The fact that Costco cakes prices are so low is certainly one of the big attractions, but they aren’t lacking on taste either!

Costco sheet cakes are popular for custom orders for any number of celebrations, from birthdays to father’s days. Costco cake designs are really easy to order as well, all you need to do is find your local store and they can take a custom order for you.

You can get a classic sponge or a chocolate base, and there are number if icings and toppings you can get too. Costco cake designs are very flexible, so can they can be made to suit most occasions, including birthdays or another special occasion (graduation, new job, etc.)

Simply fill out the Costco cake order form, which will provide you will all of your options, including icing, fillings, sponge types, and personalized messages you may need. Better still, you can arrange to pick up your cake or have it delivered – remember though, you will need to have a Costco membership!

Of course there are plenty of other options beyond Costco birthday cakes. For example, you can get bar cakes that come with chocolate mousse or vanilla mousse with fresh fruit, not to mention the various cheese cakes that are available too.

Sometimes you just want to enjoy a nice sweet treat, and Costco cakes selection isn’t lacking in that department!

Learn more about Costco Cakes and how to order by visiting their Official Website by clicking here.

  1. Dell latitude 5550
  2. Workout mirrors walmart
  3. Bug me not
  4. 200 lexus es300

The Best Desserts You Can Buy At Costco

Johnny Louis/Getty Images

By Kori Ellis/July 31, 2020 9:50 am EDT

From the Costco bakery to the freezer section and many places in between, you can find hundreds of dessert options on the shelves of this warehouse club. While many of Costco's desserts are yummy, only a select few stand above the rest as being the best of the best.

Although you may know that you should buy a rotisserie chicken each time you visit Costco, there are a few desserts that should join that $5 chicken on your must-buy list. Sure, you usually have to buy a bulk supply when you shop at Costco, but it's difficult to complain about having too many scrumptious dessert options in your home.

On this list, we'll point you toward the 15 best Costco desserts. Go ahead and sample each one with confidence, especially because each one is available at a reasonable price. At the end of this delicious journey, you'll be pleasantly surprised by the quality and diversity of the desserts you can find at Costco.

Costco Tuxedo Cake

If you love chocolate, you will fall head over heels for a Tuxedo cake from Costco. This bad boy is a chocolate lover's dream come true. On the top of a Tuxedo Cake, you'll find a rich chocolate icing covered by sticks and balls made out of dark and white chocolate. The cake is so beautiful that you might hesitate to put your fork to it. But once you gather the courage and dig in, you'll be met with a bold, rich chocolate cake along with chocolate mousse, white chocolate mousse, and pieces of chocolate brownies. Everything is so heavy and so packed with flavor that you will only be able to eat a small slice for dessert.

While everyone misses the discontinued all American chocolate cake that featured seven pounds of chocolate heaven, the Tuxedo Cake is a suitable replacement. In fact, the amazing mousse and the use of white chocolate make the Tuxedo Cake even more enjoyable. The All American Chocolate Cake was fantastic, but it became almost too rich after the third or fourth slice. The Tuxedo Cake, on the other hand, is something you will cherish until the final crumb is gone.

Churro from the Costco food court

While Costco's churro is a relatively simple creation, it's truly something you should try while you're still among the living. To make it, Costco twists up some dough, fries it, and then sprinkles it with a mixture of cinnamon and sugar. It may sound simple, but your taste buds will be overjoyed.

There are two aspects of the churro that helps elevate it to its current legendary status. First of all, Costco's churros are about 18 inches in length and satisfyingly thick. You might not think the size of a churro matters, but once you finish enjoying this thing, you won't be able to go back to smaller, punier churros ever again. Secondly, churros at Costco only cost a dollar. These days, it'd be difficult for you to find a better bang for your buck dessert anywhere else.

When you order a churro at Costco's food court, it will be hot to the touch. It's a good idea to eat it as soon as possible because that's when it will be the softest and have the most flavor.

Delizza Patisserie Belgian Mini Cream Puffs at Costco

If you start eating Delizza Patisserie Belgian Mini Cream Puffs, you will probably find it difficult to stop. Thankfully, Costco sells big boxes that contain 120 of these cream puffs, so you can stock up for snacking emergencies. That may sound like a lot, but you'll be thankful that you have a large supply once you start eating these glorious goodies.

While the flaky, golden pastry shell tastes great, where the Delizza Patisserie Belgian Mini Cream Puffs really shine is in the middle. That's where the fresh, vanilla-flavored whipped cream resides. The whipped cream has the perfect level of sweetness and a texture that will tantalize every inch of your mouth.

According to the instructions on the box, you should let these cream puffs thaw for either one hour in the refrigerator or 30 minutes at room temperature. Truthfully, though, they taste great even if they're still totally frozen. Go ahead and try one frozen cream puff. If you don't like it, you will still have 119 more to do with as you please.

Costco cheesecake

While Costco has a large selection of cheesecakes, you should start off by purchasing the regular cheesecake. It weighs four and a half pounds, but it's not even that expensive. Once you taste it, you will understand why this cheesecake is anything but regular. It may be richer and more flavorful than any cheesecake you've ever tried before. For a relatively small price tag, you can feed your entire family and still have more cheesecake to eat tomorrow.

While this so-called regular cheesecake is the best of the bunch, other cheesecakes at Costco are spectacular in their own right. Around the holiday season, there's an amazing pumpkin cheesecake that is sure to be a favorite in your household. You also can't go wrong with the New York-style cheesecake with strawberry topping. That one will also be a crowd-pleaser if you like fruity desserts.

The only cheesecakes at Costco that you should avoid are the chocolate cheesecakes. They simply lack the chocolatey goodness you can find in many of the other available desserts, especially the Tuxedo cake.

Kirkland Signature Ready-to-Freeze Vodka Cocktails from Costco


If you need to unwind after a long and stressful day, there's not a better dessert than Costco's Ready-to-Freeze Vodka Cocktails. While you may find similar products from other brands, go with those made by Costco's Kirkland Signature brand. You may actually discover that these are tastier than other, more expensive options out there.

As the name suggests, these frozen ice pops are blessed with a pleasant amount of vodka. It's not enough to make you tipsy, but it's enough to take the edge off as you relax at the end of your day. You'll also be happy to learn that each ice pop only has 100 calories, so you could hypothetically enjoy two or three of these pops without feeling any shred of guilt.

You'll find that the best flavor is Strawberry Freeze but that the Watermelon Hibiscus gives it a run for its money. The Lime Drop flavor can be shockingly sour at first, but you can learn to enjoy that one as well.

Costco cherry danish

At the bakery department of your local Costco, you can find many types of danishes. From the cheese danish to the apple danish to even the cinnamon danish, each type looks delicious. And while they all taste just as good as they look, Costco's cherry danish is the best of them all. Made with an impressive amount of real cherries, this danish is a treat that you'll savor from the first bite until the last bite.

If you want to make it even more flavorful, put the cherry danish in the microwave for a few seconds. Once it's a little bit warm, you won't believe how great this dessert will taste. Though you might be tempted to eat the entire container of danishes, just know that each one has 440 calories. Unless today is your cheat day, you probably don't want to eat more than one — or two, if no one is looking.

Costco fresh-baked pumpkin pie

Costco sells more than five million pumpkin pies each year, each one freshly baked using the same recipe that the store's used since 1987. These big pies weigh nearly four pounds but cost only $5.99. Once you try a fresh-baked pumpkin pie from Costco, you will no longer trust any other store's pumpkin pie. It's so much better than any other store-bought pumpkin pie that it's almost comical.

The crust of this pie is fantastic. The texture is perfect, and the buttery taste is equally as perfect. From there, the pumpkin pie gets even better. The filling is densely flavored with pumpkin, cinnamon, and nutmeg. It tastes like a joyous autumn afternoon distilled into its ultimate form.

While it tastes great as is, don't hesitate to add some whipped cream on top of this Costco pie. If you want to add ice cream to your dessert, French vanilla ice cream also makes for a phenomenal pairing.

David's Cookies 9" Rainbow Cake at Costco

When you first look at your David's Cookies 9" Rainbow Cake from Costco, you may be underwhelmed. Before you carve into it, it looks like a boring white cake without any festive frills. However, once you cut out a slice, you'll be thrilled by the fiesta of colors within.

Living up to its rainbow moniker, this cake has five layers beneath its inauspicious exterior. The first layer is bright red, the second layer is a deep orange, the third layer is a deep yellow, the fourth layer is an emerald green, and the fifth and final layer is a bold violet. Between every layer is a thin strip of white frosting, which allows each color to stand out beautifully.

Not only is your David's Cookies 9" Rainbow Cake aesthetically pleasing, it's also extremely tasty. The density of this cake (it actually weighs seven pounds) allows you to cut skinny slices and still keep everyone completely satisfied.

Costco butter cinnamon sugar loaves

The Butter Cinnamon Sugar Loaves from Costco are so good that they're dangerous. Even though you get three loaves per pack, they won't last in your home for more than a couple of hours. Once you take a bite, it's impossible to put down these magical loaves of sweet, sugary goodness.

You may think that the cinnamon and sugar would be the most important aspects of this loaf. But you can't underestimate the power of butter to make your bread taste incredible. One Reddit user claims that the baked loaf is completely saturated in butter before the sugar and cinnamon mixture is added on top. Based on how delicious this dessert is, we wouldn't be surprised.

While you may be tempted to add jam or more butter to Costco's Butter Cinnamon Sugar Loaves, it's really not necessary. This dessert already possesses the perfect amount of sweetness. Adding anything to it could interrupt its carefully measured equilibrium. Eat it cold or heat it up — either way, you're in for a treat.

Costco carrot walnut cake

If you see a Carrot Walnut Cake at Costco, you need to put it in your shopping cart as quickly as possible. This delicious dessert may not be available at every location at all times, so snag it when you can. This cake comes in at a whopping four pounds, so you'll have plenty to share with the rest of your family (even if you hoard some for yourself). As of last year, it boasted a relatively modest price tag, so you won't regret this purchase at all.

Costco changes everything you thought you knew about carrot cakes. In addition to the flavor of carrots, this cake also boasts toasted walnuts and sweet bits of apricot. Apricot in a carrot cake? It may sound iffy, but it works wonderfully well. The addition of fruity sweetness and a chewy texture becomes something you look forward to with each bite.

On the exterior of the Carrot Walnut Cake, you'll discover a rich frosting made with cream cheese and sugar. Costco then puts crumbs of carrot cake on the frosting to finish off the creation. If the Carrot Walnut Cake is unavailable, the Carrot Bar Cake is a suitable replacement. It's not quite as good as the four-pounder, but it's better than going home empty-handed.

Ice cream sundae from the Costco food court

If you want to eat your dessert at Costco, head to the food court for an ice cream sundae. This relatively new offering is available in two forms. You can either opt for vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate sauce or vanilla ice cream topped with strawberry sauce. While both options are well worth the $2.49 Costco charges for this dessert, the strawberry version is the real prize. With syrupy pieces of strawberry in the mix, the genuine flavor of this ice cream sundae isn't something you will soon forget.

Both versions of the ice cream sundae come in a plastic cup. If you wish, you can instead order your vanilla ice cream in a waffle cone. Although it costs only $1.99, you don't have the option of adding chocolate or strawberry sauce. While Costco has above-average ice cream, you will regret your decision to not get a sundae if you go with the waffle cone instead.

Costco tiramisu bar cake

Bad tiramisu can be bitter and feature an unappealing, soggy texture. Before you write off tiramisu for good, go to Costco and buy the tiramisu bar cake. This cake could make you realize that you actually adore this Italian dessert.

For a reasonable price, you get two and a half pounds of amazingness. Found in the refrigerated section, the tiramisu bar cake is so creamy that it will melt in your mouth in a matter of moments. While this isn't a super-sweet dessert, Costco's tiramisu doesn't have any bitterness, and it remains light and fluffy instead of soggy. It's also fancy-looking and easy to slice, which makes it a great option for when you have company over at your home.

Though it's possible to make homemade tiramisu, save yourself the aggravation and potential disaster by purchasing this dessert from Costco instead. By doing so, you'll never have to worry about eating bad tiramisu ever again.

Rians Creme Brulee at Costco

Despite what you may see on TikTok, it's really easy to make a mistake when trying to make creme brulee from scratch. Forgo the heavy lifting and head to Costco when a craving for creme brulee hits you. Rians creme brulee couldn't possibly be any better. Whether you like it hot or cold, you're going to love this stuff. Unfortunately, this dessert tends to be a seasonal offering. So, if you don't find it at your local Costco right now, start looking again right around Thanksgiving and through the end of the year.

If you want Rians creme brulee hot, the instructions on the package say to put it under your broiler on low. Keep the oven open a little bit, and take it out after about two minutes. At that point, the top of the creme brulee should be caramelized, and an extra amount of crunchiness will have been added to the equation. If you want to eat it cold, simply remove the cover, pour in the crumbles of caramel, and start shoveling it into your face. While it tastes good either way, you'll find that going the extra mile to make it hot is well worth the effort.

Costco lattice apple pie

Eating a slice of apple pie for dessert is just about the most American thing you can do at a dinner table. The lattice apple pie from Costco may very well be the best apple pie you can find at any store. The golden crust with a lattice design looks cool and tastes even better. It's the right balance between crunchy and doughy. The apple slices in the pie are flavorful on their own and are further enhanced by the presence of a generous amount of sugar and cinnamon. The apple slices aren't mushy at all, as they maintain the perfect amount of crispiness. You will enjoy it out of the box, or you could heat it up and eat it with a scoop of ice cream.

One surprising fact about Costco's lattice apple pie is that it's vegan-friendly. You'd be hard-pressed to locate a better vegan dessert than this delectable pie.


Nasto's Featured Products

When serving these desserts you will be backed by an unbeatable reputation that we have built and nurtured over the years. Every aspect of our family owned and operated business is personally supervised, therefore insuring nothing less than perfection. Our products are available to you from New Jersey headquarters, or through our many distributors.

Cake Roll
Nut Log
Vanilla Portions
Gourmet Cakes
Ice-Cream Cakes
Fresh Fruit Sorbets
Ice Cream /Gelato /Sorbet /Italian Ices

A chocolate lovers dream. Chocolate sponge cake, raspberry sauce, amaretto ice cream surround a ruby red cherry, rolled in crushed almonds and topped off with a drizzle of dark chocolate and marzipan.


An outer cushion of fresh creamy vanilla ice cream cradles an intoxicating center of rum bisque ice cream, laced with tangy citrus fruit and chopped nuts nestled next to the finest dutch cocoa, chocolate ice cream. 8 wedges are in a box.


Our original tartufo is a blend of vanilla and chocolate ice cream with sliced almonds and a cherry. Surrounded by a dark bittersweet chocolate coating. Also available in White chocolate, Peanut Butter, Pistachio, Mango/Coconut, and Pumpkin.


Our special subtle amaretto ice cream blend, is topped off with toasted macaroon crunch and ruby red cherry. 12 cups are in a box.


Cake Roll
We start with a heavenly moist devils food cake and smother it with our creamy vanilla ice cream. We then roll it into a neat snug roll and offer it to you pre-cut into 28 slices per box, or in 6” logs.


During the brisk holiday months of November thru January the Nasto family offers its valued clients a special treat. Our pre-portioned vanilla scoops are heavily dusted with a real coconut coating and topped with a festive red and green holly garnish.


Nut Log
We coat a 6” log of our creamy vanilla ice cream with a delicious layer of chocolate fudge and then roll this delectable treasure in toasted almonds.


Vanilla Portions
We supply a hearty 4oz. serving of our creamy smooth vanilla ice cream, pre-portioned for your serving convenience. Serve it solo, with a piece of cake or topping of your choice. The possibilities are endless.


Gourmet Cakes
We have many different cakes available to choose from such as a whole line of cheesecakes, our moist Red Velvet Cake, or our to die for Chocolate Fudge Cake. Ask about our cakes today.


Ice-Cream Cakes
Our fabulous Ice cream cakes are great for any occasion. Our Traditional style ice cream cake consists of Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry ice cream with a layer of toasted almonds and chocolate syrup topped with our own heavenly whipped topping. There are 7 different sizes available for purchase. We also have a nut free ice cream cake available with chocolate crunchies.


A traditional Italian dessert consisting of alternating layers of imported mascarpone and ladyfingers delicately soaked in espresso with a hint of liqueur is available in a 4lb tray or 6oz cups.


Our baked pastry shell is filled with a delicious blend of ricotta cheese, sugar, and chocolate chips. Available in both large and mini sizes.


Fresh Fruit Sorbets
The same great refreshing taste of fresh fruit sherbet without the cholesterol. Through a very gentle process fresh fruits are hollowed out, making sure none of the natural juices are lost. The fruit contents are then carefully blended with other natural ingredients to create a one of a kind phenomenal dessert. The mouthwatering sorbet is not only unique for its one of a kind taste, but its presentation is exquisite! Each flavor is presented in its own original shell.


Ice Cream /Gelato /Sorbet /Italian Ices
Our signature products are only made with finest ingredients. Starting with fresh milk and cream delivered daily by a local dairy. We use only the best Madagascar Vanilla, cocoa from Belgium, gelato flavor imported from Italy, and fresh fruits and purees. These along with our blending and freezing techniques combine to make Nasto's truly something special.

  • • Almond Joy
  • • Amaretto
  • • Avocado
  • • Banana
  • • Banana Cream Pie
  • • Black Raspberry
  • • Blueberry
  • • Blueberry Greek Yogurt
  • • Burgundy Grape
  • • Butter Pecan
  • • Butter Almond
  • • Cappuccino
  • • Cherry Vanilla
  • • Cherry Vanilla Fudge (No Sugar/No Fat)
  • • Chocolate Chip Mint
  • • Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
  • • Chocolate Chocolate Chip
  • • Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • • Cinnamon
  • • Coconut
  • • CocoLoco
  • • Coffee
  • • Cookies n Cream
  • • Dulce De Leche
  • • Fresh Cantaloupe
  • • French Vanilla
  • • Green Tea
  • • Guava
  • • Hazelnut
  • • Holy Cannoli
  • • Mallomar
  • • Mamey
  • • Mango
  • • Maple Walnut
  • • Peach
  • • Peach Yogurt
  • • Pistachio
  • • Pineapple
  • • Red Bean
  • • Rocky Road
  • • Rum Raisin
  • • Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel
  • • Strawberry
  • • Strawberry/Banana
  • • Strawberry Yogurt
  • • Sweet Corn
  • • Sweet Potato Pie
  • • Vanilla
  • • Vanilla Chocolate Chip
  • • Vanilla Fudge
  • • Vanilla Peanut Butter
  • • White Chocolate Macadamia
  • • Dutch Apple (seasonal)
  • • Egg Nog (seasonal)
  • • Pumpkin (seasonal)

  • • Apple
  • • Apricot
  • • Coconut
  • • Lemon
  • • Lime
  • • Mango
  • • Orange
  • • Passion Fruit
  • • Pear
  • • Peach
  • • Pineapple
  • • Pink Grapefruit
  • • Pomegranate
  • • Raspberry

  • • Banana
  • • Black Cherry
  • • Cappuccino
  • • Cassata Siciliana
  • • Chocolate
  • • Chocolate Habanero
  • • Chocolate Hazelnut
  • • Dulce De Leche
  • • Honey Fig
  • • Lemon Zest
  • • Pistachio
  • • Pumpkin
  • • Strawberry
  • • Toasted Almond
  • • Vanilla
  • • White Chocolate Raspberry
  • • White Hazelnut
  • • Zabaione

  • • Blue Raspberry
  • • Bubble Gum
  • • Cherry
  • • Chocolate
  • • Grape
  • • Lemon
  • • Orange
  • • Watermelon

  • • Lemon
  • • Lemon/Lime
  • • Orange
  • • Pink Champagne
  • • Raspberry
  • • Rainbow

  • • Brownies
  • • Crème Brulee
  • • Drizzle Sauces
  • • Ice Cream Pies
  • • Italian Biscotti Cookies
  • • Lava Cakes
  • • Mini Pastries
  • • Panna Cotta
  • • Party Slices
  • • Sfogliatelle
  • • Sugar Sticks
  • • Zabaglione

Costco gelato cake

💕 Salted Caramel Gelato Cake and I must have 🙌!! I’m literally checking Costco today for a mini freezer to put in the garage because I need more space for all these freezer finds 🤭



May be an image of dessert and text that says 'PRODU o F Double Layer Sponge topped with Sea Salted Caramel Ripple Gelato decorated with Caramel Curls KEEP FROZEN NET (1KG) MICHIELAN Hand Crafted SALTED CARAMEL GELATO CAKE gelateria eoligiana4 KEEP NET Double Layer Sponge Cake with Salled Caramel Ripple Gelato and decorated with Caramel Curls KEEP FROZEN NET WT.2.2 LB (1KG) MICHIELAN KEEP FROZE NET Hand Crafted SALTED CARAMEL GELATO CAKE Double Sponge Cake topped Sea Salled aramel decorated MICHIELAN KEEP FROZE'
I’m In Love With Gelato Cake
13 things Costco has decided it won't sell anymore

Costco often sends members and fans into a frenzy when news breaks of a popular item’s discontinuation.

Some departing products have inspired online petitions, others quietly disappeared from store shelves or the food court menu.

Once a product enters the warehouse chain's graveyard there’s often very little indication it’ll rise again. Take some time to mourn and remember Costco items that have come and gone throughout the years.

Here are 13 things that Costco won’t sell anymore.

1. Half-sheet cakes

Costco half sheet cake

Add Costco’s iconic half-sheet cakes to the growing list of things COVID-19 has canceled this year.

The warehouse chain shelved these sweet slabs in the spring. A staple at birthday parties, the half-sheet cakes were an inexpensive way to feed around 50 people a pop. The company informedDelish that it has no immediate plans to revive the fan favorite.

Instead, Costco has been directing people to its 10-inch round cakes, which serve about a dozen people, as a more suitable option for today’s socially distanced gatherings.

2. Polish dogs

Costco polish dog

It came as a shock to us all. To make room for more healthy items on its food court menu, Costco got rid of its Polish dogs in 2018.

The decision outraged loyal customers, who took to Twitter to protest under the hashtag #SaveThePolishDog. Sadly, their efforts were in vain, and Polish dogs are still missing from the menu.

But don’t fret, friends. You can still snag the regular, all-beef frankfurter, and Costco’s $1.50 hot dog and soda combo is in no danger of disappearing any time soon.

3. Kirkland Signature Light Beer

Kirkland Signature Light Beer

For better or for worse, Costco stopped production of its Kirkland Signature Light Beer in 2018.

The 48-packs sold for $22 — less than 50 cents per can. While the beer had a cult following of party-goers on a budget, it certainly had its critics as well.

One reviewer on RateBeer famously compared the brew’s smell to a “urine-soaked diaper sitting on a piping-hot radiator.” With feedback like that, it’s no surprise Costco didn’t keep it around.

4. All American Chocolate Cake

Costco All American Chocolate Cake

This glorious mountain of rich, chocolatey goodness was abruptly abandoned by Costco without explanation, leaving customers confused and distraught.

The four-layer chocolate cake was packed with frosting and garnished with chocolate shavings. No one knows why Costco stopped making it, only that it vanished some time in 2019 and now remains the stuff of legend.

The loss even inspired a petition on, which garnered more than 3,000 signatures.

If you're ordering anything from Costco online, be sure to use WikiBuy to compare prices and secure the lowest price available..

5. Hand-dipped ice cream bars

Costco hand dipped ice cream bar

Costco got rid of this delectable dessert way back in 2013, but seasoned shoppers remember it well.

The vanilla ice cream bar, dipped in chocolate and encrusted in toasted almonds, sold for only $1.50 at the food court.

Some speculate that rising almond and dairy prices may have prompted Costco to remove the treat from its menu, although the company has been known to sell at a loss with its roast chickens.

6. Roundup

Roundup on shelves

A petition with over 85,000 signatures may have led Costco to drop this Mosanto-owned weed-killer from store shelves.

Founder of Moms Across America, Zen Honeycutt, created a petition calling for the retailer to drop Roundup, following billion dollar lawsuits that claimed the herbicide caused cancer. Honeycutt announced on her website that she had confirmed with three people from Costco headquarters that Roundup would no longer be sold in American warehouses.

Bayer, the company that owns Monsanto, maintains that Roundup is safe to use. Yet the World Health Organization classifies Roundup’s active ingredient, glyphosate, as “probably carcinogenic to humans,” and numerous U.S. cities have either banned or restricted the substance.

7. BBQ beef brisket sandwich

Costco BBQ Beef Brisket sandwich

Although this food court favorite was only available at select Costco locations, fans grieved when the retailer swept grease aside to make room for healthier meals.

The sandwich was crammed with juicy beef dripping in sweet BBQ sauce and topped with a creamy coleslaw. At $4.99, however, it probably didn’t get the same following as cheaper items on the menu.

Fortune reported in 2018 that “at least some” warehouses had dropped the BBQ beef brisket sandwich, however Kitchnsuggested in 2019 that it occasionally resurfaces as a seasonal item.

8. Chocolate frozen yogurt

Costco frozen yogurt

Costco’s chocolate frozen yogurt was another item that didn’t make the cut when the warehouse was revamping the food court menu, though you can still get vanilla.

San Luis Obispo’s The Tribune first reported in 2018 that a Costco in the California county had discontinued the chocolate yogurt and it seems as though other locations followed.

Despite the 300 petitioners on who have refused to accept the transition, Costco doesn’t seem to plan on bringing it back.

Costco apparently swapped this tasty treat for a healthier option: an acai bowl with banana chips, granola, blueberries and strawberry slices.

9. Kirkland Signature Turkey Burgers

Kirkland Signature turkey burgers

The same year that Costco cleared many fattening items from its food court menu, it also removed this healthy item from its store shelves.

The extra-lean turkey patties, at only 200 calories each, were a welcome alternative to beef and a popular choice for customers looking to drop a few pounds.

Thankfully, the reviews for the Columbus turkey burgers currently sold at Costco have been pretty positive.

10. Kirkland Signature American Cheese

Kirkland Signature American cheese

Millennials are speedily killing off American cheese, so it comes as little surprise that Costco discontinued this Kirkland Signature product.

Unlike the still-popular Kraft Singles, Kirkland Signature cheese slices weren’t individually wrapped. Consumers disagreed about whether the convenience would be worth the wasteful packaging.

Many felt that the store brand product beat its name brand competitor in taste, but in the end Kraft has survived where Kirkland has not.

11. Fresh made gelato

Costco gelato sign

Some of you may remember this one, depending on whether your Costco food court offered it.

Some locations served gelato in flavors like strawberry, chocolate, stracciatella, pistachio or mixed berry, costing $1.50 for a three-scoop waffle cone and $4.99 for a quart to go.

A petition on (with over 100 supporters) claims Costco stopped offering gelato in 2015.

12. Kirkland Signature 5-Pocket Jeans

Kirkland Signature 5-pocket jeans

In 2016, Costco briefly discontinued its Kirkland Signature 5-Pocket Jeans for men and then reintroduced them with “design improvements.”

However, fans of the original “dad jeans” were not pleased with the changes. A customer posting on Reddit argued the newer version was a poor substitute because of its thin material and different fit and design.

Costco seems to have canceled production of these jeans entirely (possibly replacing the Kirkland Signature brand with Urban Star), according to dozens of distraught commenters on Facebook.

Costco still carries Kirkland Signature Men's Jeans; however, reviewers on the store’s website still fondly remember the 5-Pocket version.

13. Cuddle With Me dolls

Cuddle With Me doll with monkey

In 2009, Costco stopped carrying a Cuddle With Me doll that customers found racially offensive.

The dolls came in three different ethnicities — Caucasian, African American and Hispanic — and each was accompanied by a plush panda or monkey. A Costco member in North Carolina filed a complaint regarding the African American doll, which was paired with the monkey and a banana and wore a headband with the label “lil’ monkey.”

Costco immediately pulled all of the sets that included the plush monkey out of its stores. Although the other versions were available for a while, Costco seems to have banished the collection entirely.


Now discussing:

Dessert is always the best part of any meal, right? It’s our chance to indulge in a little something sweet and rich, and a great way to end a meal. There are lots of popular desserts to serve after a meal, and tiramisu is a great choice as it pairs well with any after dinner drink such as coffee, tea, wine, or even stout beer.

Does the Costco Tiramisu Score Well in Our Books?

While making this cake from scratch can be quite labor-intensive, thanks to Costco you don’t have to put all the time in, wait hours for it to chill, just so all the flavors can meld together. Costco really has put together an amazing dessert which is perfect for when you need a big dessert in a pinch, and you can even pick it up while doing your next grocery shopping trip because it keeps so well in the freezer.

Costco Tiramisu Review

The Price

The price point is hands-down the best reason to consider this dessert. The regular price for the Costco tiramisu cake is $16, but we’ve actually seen them marked down to $13 on some occasions. Your best bet is to check frequently as both availability and pricing can fluctuate.

The Number of Servings

At more than 2½ pounds of goodness, it can serve about 20 people when serving in 2 ounce portions (approximately 170 calories). For a $13-16 cake that serves 20 people, it certainly qualifies as a value-packed group dessert, as that means it will cost between $0.65-0.80 per person.

There isn’t any Alcohol in it

A tiramisu is historically made with lady fingers soaked in espresso and Marsala wine or rum. While some people swear they taste liquor in this one, the Costco version seems to have just the espresso – and no alcohol in it!

And while some people may miss the alcohol in this, having a cake with no alcohol means that more people can have it!

Costco Tiramisu Bar Cake Review

It Sticks with the Traditional Tiramisu Flavors

While a tiramisu is normally made with soaked lady fingers, this cake mostly uses coffee-soaked sponge cake with creamy mascarpone filling. It is then topped off with a sprinkle of chocolate powder, chocolate shavings or espresso beans.

Swapping out the lady fingers and removing the alcohol, is most likely how they are able to mass-produce this heavenly dessert. 

It Tastes Great

What does it taste like? A good tiramisu strikes a nice balance of being a bit sweet with a touch of bitterness as well. The sweetness comes from mildly sweetened mascarpone and the bitter flavor is from the espresso-soaked lady fingers. People often wonder whether a big box store can make a great tasting and beautiful looking dessert like tiramisu. One of the most surprising things about this dessert is how pretty the layers look when it’s cut. In my opinion, this layered dessert couldn’t be any prettier or tastier.

A purely decadent dessert, this is a splurge for the diet since it does not scrimp on calories. Thankfully, we usually consider celebrations a perfect time to cheat on our diets, so we can all give this a try. The utter creaminess of the mascarpone and cream cheese mouse if you will, is absolutely divine. It’s really the essence of what I think makes this cake so popular. Then, every once in a while you get a bite that has that strong espresso flavor, which balances it all out. But the espresso is why this dessert may not be for kids as the taste is fairly noticeable. It’s one of the main ingredients in this tiramisu and coffee certainly has a strong flavor.  

Costco Tiramisu

It’s Really Moist

I know people worry about serving cake for dessert since some cakes are a bit dry. Not to fear, this is not the case with this lovely, sweet treat! The mascarpone, which is an Italian style cream cheese with a bit of a bite, is paired here with American cream cheese to make a divinely rich, flavorful mousse that prevents this cake from being too dry. 

It Holds Up Well when Traveling or Placed in the Freezer

This version definitely travels well without losing its shape, staying intact due to a generous amount of mascarpone and cream filling. When sliced into, you can distinctly see all of the layers of espresso-dipped cake and the mascarpone and cream cheese filling.

This cake actually also holds up pretty well in the freezer. I had mine in the freezer for about 3 weeks and it was still delicious, but I probably wouldn’t recommend keeping it in the freezer for more than a month. Just make sure you let it fully defrost before serving it (I normally let it sit out overnight the night before.)

Overall – 8/10

All in all, this seems to be the perfect adult dessert as it has all the elements you’d be looking for to serve a larger group a sweet end to a dinner. This tiramisu is filled with creamy sweetness, a bit of a biting bitterness and a cool cocoa finish, all for an amazing price. Where can you find a better combination? And it gets even better when you know there won’t be any clean up! Let us know if you give this layered yummy goodness a try!

If you like this post, then we definitely recommend checking out our Gelato Cake Recipe post.

7 Best Gelato Cake Recipes


414 415 416 417 418